The philosophical basis for freedom of the press, especially in a (more or less) democratic state like our own, is that people are the ultimate decision makers, decisions are likely to be better if founded on truth than falsity, and truth is most likely to be available and widely believed with an unfettered press.Basically, I don't believe an individualized right to free speech or free press are goods unto themselves. The query has to go further - why are they important? Why did the Framers think they were important? The answer is obvious - both free press and free speech are necessary to a working system of self-government. The press for truth, and speech so that all the best ideas are heard and debated. That's why the Court's ruling in Citizens United (and the near-equivalent view for the press giving publishers, including cable providers to some extent, the right to say anything they want) was so wrong. Free speech is an illusory right when someone follows you around with a 150dB megaphone. You can't simultaneously say that free speech and press are important and then give anyone the right to simply drown or crowd others out (a right that usually only materializes with the huge resources of a corporation). Because it destroys the forum for speech itself, the crowding/drowning out should be prohibited by the First Amendment, not protected by it.
Showing posts with label Journalism Ratings Board. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Journalism Ratings Board. Show all posts
7.19.2010
The Inherent Limits on Freedom of the Press
Ok, so I just saw a blog post that mirrors my views on the inherent limits on press freedom and the reasons for it exactly, so I thought I'd share. Stanford philosophy professor John Perry writes:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)