Showing posts with label homophobia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label homophobia. Show all posts

4.21.2011

Privilege Is That Which You Take for Granted

TransGriot
I was sort of daydreaming a day or two ago, waiting for the time (oh so close, yet oh so very far away) when I will no longer be a law student, and when I will be done with the bar exam. I was thinking how nice it would be to travel abroad for a bit. Then in that radical whimsy (by law student standards) that comes with daydreaming, I imagined that wow, it'd be cool to live abroad for some time. Then my thoughts turned to what it might be like to live in a country with an official religion, say Christianity. (Of course many of our current politicians believe the this is one such country, but I digress.) I got a little creeped out at the thought. The reason is that in this thought experiment, there is an official government declaration that because I am Jewish, I am other.

4.15.2011

Michigan Law's Lesson in How Not to Treat a Student Body

Respecting someone's right to have an opinion is fundamentally different than respecting that opinion. Inviting someone who votes for constitutional amendments to ban gay marriage to speak at our graduation? That's an example of the latter.

I am sad to say that I attended a meeting this morning where I proposed a walkout of my own commencement ceremony. Our Dean, Evan Caminker, oblivious to the needs of his own students, has invited Rob Portman to speak at our Senior Day. Rob Portman is a distinguished alumnus of our fine institution, the junior Senator from Ohio, and, of course, a raging homophobe. Senator Portman:
  1. Voted YES on Constitutional Amendment banning same-sex marriage.
  2. Voted YES on banning gay adoptions in DC.
  3. Supports a continued ban on gay people serving in the military.

3.02.2011

The Court Wields Its First Amendment Cudgel and Misses the Mark


Today the Court decided Snyder v. Phelps, the case about the Westboro Baptist Church's anti-gay picketing of military funerals. Snyder had won a jury verdict on intentional infliction of emotional distress (IIED), a relatively recently created tort that applies to conduct so "outrageous" that it goes beyond the bounds of what society finds acceptable. This was a tough case that pitted a First Amendment right to speak on matters of public concern against a non-public figure's right to privacy. The decision came down 8-1 on the side of the church, and I think their analysis misses the point. Strangely enough, and in a way that may destroy any ACLU cred I have, I find myself agreeing with Justice Alito in dissent, and those are not words I expected to find myself typing.

11.10.2010

Andrew Shirvell Fired, How Long Until the Frivolous Lawsuit?


In a victory for the rational, the tolerant, and opponents of First-Amendment sloganeering, Andrew Shirvell was fired from the Michigan Attorney General's office on Monday. I wrote about this last month, when the controversy blew up in the first place. As I said then:
His boss, Attorney General Mike Cox has lightly condemned the behavior as showing "immaturity and a lack of judgment", but also saying that becuase it's not on work time, Shirvell has a First Amendment right to say these things. In reaction to the order from Gov. Granholm to suspend him, Cox says: ""I don't know why she's so freaking irresponsible. ... she went to Harvard Law School," Cox said. "The civil service rules are a huge shield for free speech and she knows that." Cox's views reflects a broad misconception about the First Amendment held by, I'd argue, most US citizens.

10.01.2010

What does Mike Cox think the First Amendment means?

A big story this week has been the absurd and patently offensive antics of Andrew Shirvell, the Michigan Assistant Attorney General who is viciously attacking Chris Armstrong, the openly gay twenty-one year old President of the University of Michigan Student Assembly. To get that point across loud and clear, he's an AAG, employed by the State of Michigan, attacking a twenty-one year old gay kid. Shirvell has attacked Armstrong's "homosexual agenda," posted a pciture with a swastika pasted over it, called him a “racist, elitist liar,” and claimed that he’s “Satan’s representative on the student assembly.” He also has had, for six months, a blog dedicated to attacking Armstrong, much of which, if actually believed, very likely makes him liable in a defamation suit (no link - google it if you want).

So, despite this truly despicable behavior, Shirvell is still an Assistant Attorney General. Though as of this morning, he was apparently suspended (update: it's apparently a "leave of absence"). His boss, Attorney General Mike Cox has lightly condemned the behavior as showing "immaturity and a lack of judgment", but also saying that becuase it's not on work time, Shirvell has a First Amendment right to say these things. In reaction to the order from Gov. Granholm to suspend him, Cox says: ""I don't know why she's so freaking irresponsible. ... she went to Harvard Law School," Cox said. "The civil service rules are a huge shield for free speech and she knows that." Cox's views reflects a broad misconception about the First Amendment held by, I'd argue, most US citizens - one which I'd like to clear up.

7.08.2010

The Constitutionally Offensive Defense of Marriage

And another wall comes crumbling down. Judge Tauro, up in federal court in Boston, just found that DOMA violates the both the rights of states to define marriage and equal protection in the U.S. Constitution. (federalism decision here and equal protection decision here)

3.22.2010

Hate Speech and the Tea Party

(updated below)

Another post on language? Is this a theme? Ok, so I think about language a lot, perhaps as intertwined with the general concepts of speech and First Amendment rights. And judging from conservations with all other members of this blog, we'll go back and forth responding to similar ideas. Personally, I really struggle with that line on the First Amendment where hate speech falls - is it an action designed solely to injure? Is it political speech in any sense? Lately I've become more sympathetic to the Critical Race Theory approach, which is that hate speech is particular should be punishable in some way, but I'm still not sure. For all our liberal readers that have not yet explored the radical, Words That Wound is a collection of the seminal critical race essays on the subject, by Mari Matsuda, Kim Crenshaw, Richard Delgado, and Charles Lawrence III, and well worth the mind-opening read.

Anyway, so this post was prompted by that oh so wonderful new-ish political movement, the Tea Party, and protestors' decisions to call Rep. John Lewis one of the words Jacob says we should have removed from our vocabularies loooong ago, and call Rep. Barney Frank another. I agree completely with Jacob that we need to monitor our own speech and be conscious of the results of it, but the difficulty is in the next step - can law be involved?