Showing posts with label political advertising. Show all posts
Showing posts with label political advertising. Show all posts

10.20.2010

Why Judicial Elections Make No Sense

Judicial elections make no sense. I just saw a TV advertisement in Michigan called "Fair and Just." (The link is to an announcement of the ads - I couldn't find the video online.) The advertisement is for two judicial candidates for the Michigan Supreme Court and says the following things:
  1. The judges will apply the law faithfully.
  2. The judges will be TOUGH on crime and they're "law and order" judges.
  3. The judges will be "fair and just."
  4. Bad decisions can cost us jobs.
The first item is standard dogwhistle code for "These judges are Republicans/loyal conservatives," which apparently the ad is not allowed or not advised to say. Regarding the second and third items, in what universe do those two statements not contradict each other? If you know ahead of time that the judges will be tough on crime, how is it possible that they are either fair or just? Tough on crime inherently means worse for criminal defendants, and regardless of your opinion of criminal defendants, a preordained result is by its nature neither fair nor just. Comparing the first and third statements gives you the same absurd result. This just makes no sense. I'll discuss the fourth point shortly.