Showing posts with label liberals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label liberals. Show all posts

4.03.2010

The Difference Between Liberals and Conservatives

Paul Krugman has a blog post up today explaining that liberals and conservatives are not mirror images, that just because they are obsessed with small government for its own sake, it doesn't mean we want big government for its own sake. We want government to be involved where it's needed to produce results.

Jon Chait actually wrote a great piece about this in 2005 where he goes into a lot more detail, but comes to the same conclusion. I think this explains a lot about our current political culture, and how we're always talking past each other. Sadly, I think both sides misunderstand this.

Conservatarians: Liberals do not want big government for its own sake. Not a single one does. Get that straight. We mostly don't care one way or another about the "evils" of big government - we just want to help people and combat some of the inherent unfairness of life.

Liberals: It's not that conservatives/libertarians hate poor and black people. They just don't care one way or another whether people die from lack of health care or can't get jobs or political power because of their being born poor or black, as long as government is small enough for us to be free.

Yeah, I think I'm on the right side of this one.

Oh, and a quote from Jon Chait's piece (in 2005, remember) might explain why so many conservatives today actually believe liberals are socialist:
If liberalism is not the mirror image of conservatism, what is? The more apt parallel is probably socialism. True socialists believe that allowing capitalists to keep some of the fruits of workers' labor is inherently immoral. They also tend to believe that free enterprise does not work very well. But, like the conservative belief that big government doesn't work well, this empirical belief merely sits atop a deeper normative belief. For committed socialists, doing away with 'exploitation' is an end in itself.
If they believe we want big government for its own sake, they actually believe we're socialist. Believe it or not, it's totally logically consistent!