Showing posts with label mainstream discourse. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mainstream discourse. Show all posts

11.02.2010

The Rally Lived Up to Its Promise of False Equivalence

The Rally to Restore Sanity and/or Fear happened this weekend. It was surprisingly as apolitical as Stewart and Colbert had promised, and perhaps even anti-political. They never even said to go vote, which, in a non-partisan fashion, would have absolutely been the right message. As exciting as it was, in this regard, the rally may well have done more damage than good.

First, as I pointed out before, the promise of this rally was one of pure false equivalence, basically between Fox News and MSNBC. This is something that gets me consistently lecturing people in real life, something that Jon Stewart knows better than to do, and something he usually doesn't do. Keith Olbermann, in response to the rally, said two things: 1) The message of ratcheting down the tone was not lost on him, and so he is suspending the "Worst Person in the World" segment. (Kudos to him for being responsive - this is a great move.); and more importantly, 2) he called out Jon Stewart on the false equivalence between MSNBC and Fox. This might seem self-serving, but he's absolutely right. In a way, Stewart's lambasting of both sides is, ironically, his own form of fearmongering rhetoric about the health our of discourse. Here's the Olbermann clip. It's well worth watching.

6.03.2010

White Terrorists Have Predictable Behavior, So They Don't Count

Channing Kennedy has a very good post up at RaceWire about the good and the bad about the new National Security Strategy. The good:
There’s a lot improved over the previous version from 2006 (the one that used the word “preemption”), and a lot to praise. The Obama version doesn’t use the phrase the “War on Terror” or “radical Islam,” and it reiterates the administration’s intentions to close Gitmo; it’s not afraid of a “multipolar” world power structure. And it’s not every National Security Strategy that calls to “Promote Dignity by Meeting Basic Needs” via cooperative efforts to eradicate extreme poverty and childhood illness in Africa.

5.10.2010

Obama Contributes to the Noise (Part II - The Not So Good)


This is the second half of the review of President Obama's commencement address at the University of Michigan this past Saturday. The first half is here, and the text of the speech is here.

Ok, so I still think that on the whole Obama's speech was fantastic, but there are two glaring flaws, one of which I'd like to just note - his hypocrisy on our democracy, and the other of which this post is primarily about - the false equivalence between right and left. After that, there's one more side point I'd like to address - the lack of even a mention of other problems with the media - particularly with respect to race.

5.03.2010

Obama's Still Got It (Part I - The Good)

(updated below)


Yesterday, President Obama gave the commencement address at Michigan, and I immediately realized that a) I was basically the only law student that didn't see it (I was at a friend's wedding - congrats again Johnny and Jen!), b) it was worth the hours of waiting in line, and c) it was a speech that could have been designed just for me (I was told so by several friends). So I read through it, and I almost began tearing up and couldn't stop smiling, except in the points where I wanted to yell out that he's being a hypocrite. And again, this was just while I was reading (full text here). But I've also seen enough of his speeches that I could recreate the delivery in my own head. Anyway, given my varied and strong reactions to his address, I figured I'd write about the different parts. This post is incredibly long, so I'll write here about the good, and about the bad separately.

4.03.2010

The Difference Between Liberals and Conservatives

Paul Krugman has a blog post up today explaining that liberals and conservatives are not mirror images, that just because they are obsessed with small government for its own sake, it doesn't mean we want big government for its own sake. We want government to be involved where it's needed to produce results.

Jon Chait actually wrote a great piece about this in 2005 where he goes into a lot more detail, but comes to the same conclusion. I think this explains a lot about our current political culture, and how we're always talking past each other. Sadly, I think both sides misunderstand this.

Conservatarians: Liberals do not want big government for its own sake. Not a single one does. Get that straight. We mostly don't care one way or another about the "evils" of big government - we just want to help people and combat some of the inherent unfairness of life.

Liberals: It's not that conservatives/libertarians hate poor and black people. They just don't care one way or another whether people die from lack of health care or can't get jobs or political power because of their being born poor or black, as long as government is small enough for us to be free.

Yeah, I think I'm on the right side of this one.

Oh, and a quote from Jon Chait's piece (in 2005, remember) might explain why so many conservatives today actually believe liberals are socialist:
If liberalism is not the mirror image of conservatism, what is? The more apt parallel is probably socialism. True socialists believe that allowing capitalists to keep some of the fruits of workers' labor is inherently immoral. They also tend to believe that free enterprise does not work very well. But, like the conservative belief that big government doesn't work well, this empirical belief merely sits atop a deeper normative belief. For committed socialists, doing away with 'exploitation' is an end in itself.
If they believe we want big government for its own sake, they actually believe we're socialist. Believe it or not, it's totally logically consistent!

3.24.2010

Small Policy Choices in the Future of News

The future of news is a hot topic these days. One troubling trend, however, among those that oppose reform of the established media is to just sort of hand-wave and say, "oh the internet will take care of it all."

What these people have to realize is that policy choices made by the people who shape the internet will have huge consequences for the future of the internet, and probably none are quite as big as net neutrality.

Here's one smaller example:
The question is this. If Twitter is a news-delivery service, and I believe it is, what are the real dimensions of a nugget of news?

...

The actual number, the average [character] length of a Times "nugget-of-news" is this: 185

...

[T]he answer is fairly clear. 140 [characters] is not enough, not even for the average nugget. And to be able to hold the largest one, the max would have to be 250 or 300. And there would be no room for the link, even shortened, in that size nugget.
So the future of news seems to rely heavily on new technologies like twitter. I don't doubt for a second that that's true, and we're already seeing it. It's just important to understand that policy choices in the structure of these technologies, even as small as how many characters to allow per tweet, can have huge impacts on our future discourse.

3.22.2010

Some perspective, please?

How did our discourse get to this point?

I'm really just sick of discussing this health care bill already. Yeah, it passed. Cool. But we've been talking about it for, counting the campaigns, three years. I'm sick of it. But what people are actually saying about it fascinates me (in some horrifying train-wreck sorta way).