Showing posts with label rally to restore sanity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rally to restore sanity. Show all posts
11.17.2010
The Rally From Nowhere, continued.
Jon Stewart recently sat down with Rachel Maddow in order to defend himself against criticisms from all over the left, including here, that the Rally to Restore Sanity essentially served as a huge banner of false equivalence. Particularly stinging was Bill Maher's criticism, saying "If you’re going to have a rally where hundreds of thousands of people show up, you might as well go ahead and make it about something."
Jay Rosen posted his own commentary about the interview in YouTube form, along with the full interview, Bill Maher's clip, and an old Daily Show takedown of CNN's false equivalence here. All the videos are well worth watching. I just wanted to highlight two points that Jay found very interesting which relate back to a lot of what I love about his own work: 1) Jon felt the need to come and defend himself because he wants a news system that focuses not on the left/right, Dem/GOP, blue/red fight, but the conflict between, as Jay put it, corruption and virtue. 2) Jon stresses to Rachel over and over that he is on the sidelines and is thus different from Rachel, and she fights him on it.
11.02.2010
The Rally Lived Up to Its Promise of False Equivalence
The Rally to Restore Sanity and/or Fear happened this weekend. It was surprisingly as apolitical as Stewart and Colbert had promised, and perhaps even anti-political. They never even said to go vote, which, in a non-partisan fashion, would have absolutely been the right message. As exciting as it was, in this regard, the rally may well have done more damage than good.
First, as I pointed out before, the promise of this rally was one of pure false equivalence, basically between Fox News and MSNBC. This is something that gets me consistently lecturing people in real life, something that Jon Stewart knows better than to do, and something he usually doesn't do. Keith Olbermann, in response to the rally, said two things: 1) The message of ratcheting down the tone was not lost on him, and so he is suspending the "Worst Person in the World" segment. (Kudos to him for being responsive - this is a great move.); and more importantly, 2) he called out Jon Stewart on the false equivalence between MSNBC and Fox. This might seem self-serving, but he's absolutely right. In a way, Stewart's lambasting of both sides is, ironically, his own form of fearmongering rhetoric about the health our of discourse. Here's the Olbermann clip. It's well worth watching.
First, as I pointed out before, the promise of this rally was one of pure false equivalence, basically between Fox News and MSNBC. This is something that gets me consistently lecturing people in real life, something that Jon Stewart knows better than to do, and something he usually doesn't do. Keith Olbermann, in response to the rally, said two things: 1) The message of ratcheting down the tone was not lost on him, and so he is suspending the "Worst Person in the World" segment. (Kudos to him for being responsive - this is a great move.); and more importantly, 2) he called out Jon Stewart on the false equivalence between MSNBC and Fox. This might seem self-serving, but he's absolutely right. In a way, Stewart's lambasting of both sides is, ironically, his own form of fearmongering rhetoric about the health our of discourse. Here's the Olbermann clip. It's well worth watching.
9.19.2010
Restoring Sanity to "Both Sides"
By now, most of you will have heard about Jon Stewart's "Rally to Restore Sanity", which coupled with Stephen Colbert's "March to Keep Fear Alive," will give Glenn Beck's rally the sound mocking it deserves. I just wanted to write a quick note about it right now. A more thorough post on the genesis of this event and what that means generally for media will be coming soon.
Basically, Jon Stewart is great, and I'm a huge fan, but when he announced this rally he did something I believe deeply destructive and have written about before - false equivalences. Glenn Greenwald, however, just wrote the post that I wanted to write, so I'm just going pass it on, quoting him:
Basically, Jon Stewart is great, and I'm a huge fan, but when he announced this rally he did something I believe deeply destructive and have written about before - false equivalences. Glenn Greenwald, however, just wrote the post that I wanted to write, so I'm just going pass it on, quoting him:
I think Jon Stewart is one of the most incisive and effective commentators in the country, and he reaches an audience that would otherwise be politically disengaged. I don't have any objection if he really wants to hold a rally in favor of rhetorical moderation, and it's also fine if, as seems to be the case, he's eager to target rhetorical excesses on both the left and right in order to demonstrate his non-ideological centrism. But the example he chose to prove that the left is guilty, too -- the proposition that Bush is a "war criminal" -- is an extremely poor one given that the General in charge of formally investigating detainee abuse (not exactly someone with a history of Leftist advocacy) has declared this to be the case, and core Nuremberg principles compel the same conclusion.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


